Independent reviews of food dehydrators, from $65 stackers to stainless shelf modelsHow we make money

Home / Comparisons

Comparison

Cosori Premium vs Magic Mill

Two stainless shelf dehydrators around $160 to $200.

The Cosori Premium is the more temperature-accurate and compact choice, while the Magic Mill MFD-7070 adds a seventh stainless tray and scored higher overall in TechGearLab's test.

By The Dehydrator Report Editors · Updated November 11, 2026 · 4 min read

We may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page. It never decides what we recommend. How we make money.

Cosori Premium Food Dehydrator (CP267-FD)Magic Mill Food Dehydrator (MFD-7070)

Both have stainless trays, rear fans and digital timers. They're close enough that size and price usually decide.

Side by side

As of November 11, 2026. Prices are list or typical prices.
Cosori PremiumMagic Mill MFD-7070
Price$159.99 list$199.99 list
Trays6 stainless steel7 stainless steel, 13 × 12 in
Drying areaAbout 6 sq ftAbout 7.6 sq ft
Temperature95–165°F95–167°F
Timer48 hr24 hr

In testing

TechGearLab gave the Magic Mill its highest overall score (83 to the Cosori's 74). The Cosori was the most temperature-accurate model it tested, never varying more than three degrees. Food Network named the Cosori best overall and the Magic Mill best for fruit and vegetables.

Size

The Cosori is 13.4 × 17.8 × 12.4 in. The Magic Mill is 17.75 × 13.5 × 12.25 in and 18.5 lb, with one more tray.

Which should you buy?

Choose the Cosori Premium if

You want the most accurate temperature and a 48-hour timer for less.

Choose the Magic Mill MFD-7070 if

You want a seventh tray and quieter running.

Questions

Which is better for fruit leather?

Both did well for Food Network. The Cosori includes a roll sheet.

Sources

Keep reading